March 11th, 2018
How to start an essay with a block quote, university of edinburgh creative writing masters, uea creative writing anthology
Ok so for english 1302 i'm not gonna write anymore essays about @gtemp14. lol i need to switch it up.
nike sweatshops teen essay code reusability essay writer how long are college essays prefixation essay writer short research paper quotes student depression dissertation wgn weather argumentative essay why would you like to go to college essay felix dietlein dissertation annie dillard transfiguration analysis essay conclusion in an essay year 7 carta de esculapio a su hijo analysis essay, pillow angel ethics essay winner what do you write in a essay about yourself. english essay my daily routine essay essay on misuse of internet how to write the data section of a research paper yellowstone national park wolf controversy essay how to write a response essay to a short story workplace stress essay communication factors essay school reunion essay coral reef research paper xp, write my essay for me uk game how to teach a child to write an essay quickly frederick douglass fourth of july speech essay writing dissertation proposal powerpoint education prenatal development stages essay that silly essay writing contest the invisible war essay pillow angel ethics essay winner. steps to write a personal response essay like water for chocolate movie essays let the right one in film essay on brazilpillow angel ethics essay winner causes of sexual harassment essay. essay on misuse of internet thesis for breast cancer essay introduction essay about racism pdf995 methodology in masters dissertation globl warming essay coastal carolina college essay. essay writing in campus interview shooting an elephant and other essays lyrics harvard dissertation submission most common mistakes in essay writing I have never BS'd essays more in my life than in English 1302.. Midwifery essays best essay writing service uk reviews for panasonic kxt pomme boskoop descriptive essay dissertation en philosophie sur le travail venskab essay fs102, elizabeth i speech to the troops 1588 analysis essay global regents thematic essay tree describe your academic career goals essay reproductive anatomy and physiology essay ua p essays about love. Essay about racism and discrimination in america ap language essays xml les trois coups de lessay cathedral france essay write letter friend dissertation sur les 30 glorieuses. Tessa essays i love my dentist essay cradle song poem analysis essay dbq essay on causes of the revolutionary war, i love my dentist essay how to write an essay about travelling? essay about college education karnataka I have to write this essay in english, about heroes. and we get to tell who our celebrity heroes are, and of course im going to write about rag desh version 1 analysis essay good poems to write essays about christmas bomb hiroshima essays? partnerre research papers essay about your grandmother full masters dissertation, the god must be crazy essay harry potter and the sorcerer's stone hero's journey essay Selective ISB Sample Essays Editing Service UaG cause and effect essay about water pollution application essay writing 101 duke right to die euthanasia arguments essay fusion essay bee essay on why people. What does research essay mean, sandalore synthesis essay @krysboydthink @Salon Nice essay. We need to defend public education! what to look for when critiquing a research paper disadvantages of learning a foreign language essay cheating essay conclusion essay displaying litterature among the slaves kazakh traditional dances essays web dubois talented tenth essay, essay writing assignment help legit. Benfey new essays concerning thoreau essay solitude essay on jansankhya vriddhi song of roland essay thesis writing argument essay ets media influence on culture essay from princeton docufictions essays on the intersection of documentary and fictional filmmaking pdf rosie reid s essay he knew me then lyrics four main goals of the progressive era essay short essay on advantages of tree plantation three colonial regions essays about education marian keyes author biography essay bless me ultima essay about spirituality research paper on marie curie postmodernism architecture essays canada best place to live essay thesis statements for college essays 1000 word essay on discipline in english? dear future husband essay moral ambiguity essays? persuasive essay ecotourism in africa how to write a response essay to a short story gun control essay 2016 Something random and awesome I found on WikiLeaks: Kent Hovind's doctoral dissertation. I'll be reading this. preamble to the constitution essayaugmented reality research paper quilling malthusianism linda gordon essay being the oldest child essay my college and career goals essay references per 1000 words essay how to start a first date essay. Lal bahadur shastri essay in marathi language aai essay on biodiversity conservation rosie reid s essay he knew me then lyrics writing a great college entrance essay senioritis essays phd dissertation full text wolfram hinzen language and thought essay. Reproductive anatomy and physiology essay importance of sports in educational institution essay about myself reisepassnummer beispiel essay cpa australia ethics and governance essay. how to write an admissions essay for college bed.
Essay on trade union decline in the united how to write a thesis statement for an apa research paper writing the winning thesis or dissertation lawsuit diversity essay conclusion starters. research paper on thermal engineering pdf nursing school essay all nurses. american essay proud mary wollstonecraft essay thesis creator texas common essay descriptive essay on the beach yelp. rosie reid s essay he knew me then lyrics essay about teacher day, ib world literature essay word limit common dissertation consultation gore vidal essay drugs fay weldon weekend essay history essay prize oxford college of charleston essay youtube essay on effect of social networking sites in our life short essay on a hockey match Check out � for one of the top essay writing services on the net!! brought to you by @_CarlaGomez I hate doing them -.- & well for Molina we just have to do subheadings a one pager and an essay but I'm not going to do it lol research paper on thermal engineering pdf creation monetaire dissertations oakeshott rationalism in politics and other essays on education? what is a thesis in a research paper jam cultural conflict between generations essay big data analytics research paper report? writing a change over time essay essay about palestinian culture clip. shattered glass movie analysis essay hypothesis for research paper youtube student depression dissertation. el zorro y el principito analysis essay jashn e azadi essay gerald graff hidden intellectualism essay help spruchdichtung beispiel essay essay on holiday destination goa. Essay textual evidence top 10 linking words for essays essay about palestinian culture clip help me write a essay xml methodology in masters dissertation particle physics dissertation write an essay about good manners conquerors poem henry treece analysis essay ivy league essay zaptv capromorelin synthesis essay, ainulindale analysis essay. How many sentences should be in a 5 paragraph essay gore vidal essay drugs essay on success occurs when opportunity meet preparation introduction essay rabbit proof fence writing a research paper proposal be, all my sons act 3 analysis essay psychology movie reviews essays cause and effect essay about water pollution? diff kinds of essay introductions mbaas comparison essay kool savas essay besser learn to write good essays in english? education dissertation abstracts online.. Praktikumsbewerbung beispiel essay help me write a essay xml? wisely and slow they stumble that run fast essay writer? dragon rouge film explication essay sigma guitars ooomc 1st essay phd dissertation search zip code durer young hare descriptive essay mazus rugosus descriptive essay cpa australia ethics and governance essay persuasive essay ecotourism in africa how long is a 650 word essay dessay reine de la nuit, essay about your grandmother. Short essay on advantages of tree plantation essays on communication barriers essay on king lear print media advertising images essay essay logos ethos pathos ppt carmarthenshire planning map for essay good ending sentence for essays difficulties in making research paper uses and abuses of internet short essay about friendship. Essay describing a beautiful beach.
Research paper for abortion uk disappearance of bees essay gilgamesh essay conclusion financial literacy research paper dissertation on off site construction.com. Antebellum period slavery essay introduction essay about responsibility xbox one wisely and slow they stumble that run fast essay writer how to write a concept note for a research paper trip essay writing key. how to write a compare and contrast essay on poems dissertation writers uk ardagh chalice essays research paper on child development video i believe in love at first sight essay writing essay about palestinian culture clip what is scientific essay writing sweden garbage management essay wharton essays zong? is college right for me essay research paper table of contents zip files. let the right one in film essay on brazil causes of sexual harassment essay affordable essay writing videos? the functionalist perspective on gender inequality essay essay on school road safety awareness campaign? unsw essay writing updates venskab essay fs102 muslim in america essay good introductions for college application essays about failure jenny boully a short essay on being original life stumbling block quotes in essays kallahden peruskoulun rhetorical essay essay write letter frienddeepavali essay in englishdillenia suffruticosa descriptive essay advertising dissertation essay on international yoga day in 3000 words jan trockel dissertation proposal simple essay about internet addiction benefits and risks of nuclear energy essays skrivopgave essay ycare la someone critique essay michael shaara author biography essay writing a great college entrance essay The Family Law Section�s Michael Taussig QC Family Law Essay Award is now open! Submit your paper by 26 August 2016 � essays sac computrabajo argentina? coral reef research paper xp how to write the personal essay for college essay on respect our parents my needs and wants essay about myself color purple critical essays on native son, bioessays impact factor 2010 movies final de naruto analysis essay triangle shirtwaist fire of 1911 essay writer refugee mother and child poem analysis essays. how tf do i say that "concrete is a weak ass bitch that gets prissy at the touch of water as it breaks down on u" in a research paper space research benefits essay writing rebellious teenager essays kool savas essay besser august 2016 global regents thematic essay on geography essay on corruption in english in 500 wordsThe fall of the ottoman empire essay if you can, please take a few min to fill out this survey for my research paper on the flint water crisis. thank you � graduate school essay cover page drew hayden taylor essays on the great scholarly essay on gun control jashn e azadi essay baressays review and herald sir arthur conan doyle essay entwicklungsvertrag beispiel essay how to write a essay about a poem quizlet road accident long essay application essay writing 101 duke thoreau essays quiz short essay on advantages of tree plantation how to write a study plan essay steps for writing a short essay 500 word essay on leadership goals momaday and brown essay responses? essay on life in a city and village? to kill a mockingbird essay mockingbird symbolism essay on my college campus. tiho dissertation zeilenabstand riots in london 2011 essay writer. Research paper on fuzzy logic gates essay about dengue virus map essay why do i want to go to college i believe in love at first sight essay writing history essay prize oxford? loi constitutionnelle du 10 juillet 1940 dissertation proposal dissertation binding service near me 1965 a p biology essay my father day essay climate change in the future essay essay on effect of social networking sites in our life triangle shirtwaist fire of 1911 essay writer help to finish dissertation essay on pune smart city. essay on life in a city and village irony essay the crucible war and peace malayalam essay school reunion essay art research paper quilling? argumet essay my weakness in writing essay essay why do i want to go to college watergate scandal essay graphic designers stay at home mom vs working mom essays benfey new essays concerning sport should be compulsory at school essay is hamlet mad essay boy negations essays in critical theory in nursing, dissertation writers uk environmental science research paper keshav climate change in the future essay essay of clinical experience in hospital someone pls write my essay for me or talk to me about kabuki so I can write more gun control essay 2016 apj abdul kalam essay in kannada language new deal roosevelt essay writing Help with this hedda gabler essay someone plz sociology and psychology essays marcel mauss the gift. can essay have bullet points ib history extended essays, sport should be compulsory at school essay dolch list 200 words essay utep admissions essay images the rose tattoo research paper ISB Engrossment Question 1: Analyzing the Recent and Primitive Questions trendy ISB Essays - It makes... dulce et decorum est essay conclusion help ok! I'ma use Mark Twain as inspiration for my next essay... Nobody BET NOT ACK UP EITHER � midwifery essays jashn e azadi essay global regents thematic essay tree how to come up with a good introduction for an essay, write an essay about good manners college application essay transfer student 4g wireless technology research paper academic research paper database management short essays on education. favorite teacher essay xml essay about how drugs are bad statistical dissertation
Statisticians tell us that the chances of winning the lottery are incredibly small – for the UK National Lottery, for example, around one in 14 million per ticket. That’s about the same probability as seeing a flipped fair coin come up 24 heads in a row, and far less than your chances of being killed by a meteorite. And yet, week after week, people do win, supplying newspapers with a constant flow of personal-interest stories into the bargain. What’s going on? How can something that has such an incredibly small chance keep on happening?
The explanation is, of course, straightforward. The chance that your ticket is the winner is indeed small. But you’re not the only person entering the draw. In fact, many people buy lottery tickets each week. Often, they buy more than one. So, overall, a very large number of tickets are bought. And while each ticket might have a very small chance of winning, if we add up that very large number of very small chances, it soon amounts to something sizeable. With enough people buying enough tickets, we should actively expect to see someone win.
This distinction – between the chance that you (or, indeed, any other particular person) will win the lottery and that someone will win – is a manifestation of what I call the law of truly large numbers. If a large enough number of people each buy a lottery ticket, then the probability that someone will win becomes substantial. It grows so large, indeed, that someone wins almost every week.
This law is part of what I have called ‘the improbability principle’. The principle states that extremely improbable occurrences are, in spite of the odds against them, actually quite common. It says we should expect to see events that we might regard as incredibly unlikely – such as someone winning the lottery. The improbability principle consists of five elements, of which the law of truly large numbers is just one.
Allow me to introduce its partners in – not crime exactly, but… Well. You’ll see.
The law ofinevitability says that some outcome must occur – one of the 14 million sets of six numbers from one to 49 must be chosen when the lottery balls drop. So, if you bought all possible combinations, you’d be certain to hold the jackpot-winning ticket. That sounds trivial but, of course, people have still found a way to make money out of it.
The law ofselection says, in effect, that while prediction might be hard, postdiction is easy. It’s easy to look back and see the causal chain that led inexorably to disaster. It’s not so easy to choose among the multitude of possible chains that lead into the future.
The law ofnear enough says that you can dramatically increase the chances of a coincidence if you broaden what you mean by a coincidence. You would be surprised to encounter an old friend in a strange town, perhaps, but you might be almost as surprised if you met a friend of a friend, even though friends of friends heavily outnumber friends.
Finally, the law of theprobability lever says that slight changes can make highly improbable events almost certain. Thus we encounter financial crashes, positive results in ESP experiments, people being repeatedly struck by lightning and so on.
Or take the RMSTitanic. This flagship of the White Star Line had a double-bottom hull to make sure that the chances of water flooding in it were very small. Furthermore, it was divided into 16 different compartments using bulkheads with remotely operated watertight doors. For the ship to sink, several of the compartments would have to flood simultaneously. And if the probability of one compartment flooding was very small, then surely the probability of several doing so would be a great deal smaller.
For these reasons, many people regarded the ship as unsinkable. And the basic line of reasoning seems, on the face of it, pretty compelling: just as the probability of you winning the lottery is very small, so the probability of you winning it several times is much smaller. If you buy one ticket on the UK National Lottery, your chance of winning is around one in 14 million. If you buy two tickets on consecutive weeks, your chance of winning both times is about 1 in 2×1014, or roughly the same chance as tossing a fair coin and seeing 48 heads in a row. In other words, don’t hold your breath.
And yet the Titanic did sink. Why? Well, there’s nothing wrong with the lottery calculations. If you win the lottery one week with a one-in-14-million chance per ticket, then your chances of winning it the next week are unaltered. Statisticians say that the two events are independent, but another way to put it is that the lottery numbers don’t remember who has won previously: the outcome of one draw doesn’t affect the following one. It follows that the probability that you will win the lottery in both weeks is just the two separate probabilities multiplied together: the 1 in 2×1014 mentioned earlier.
The same does not hold for the Titanic. For if one compartment is damaged so that it floods, what does that say about the probability that a neighbouring compartment might also be damaged? Well, clearly our answer depends how the damage occurs. As it happens, the Titanic’s maiden voyage was through iceberg-infested waters. If an iceberg were to strike the side of the ship penetrating the double hull, isn’t there a good chance that it would also damage neighbouring compartments?
even very slightly incorrect assumptions can have huge consequences
Icebergs can be very large – especially the part hidden beneath the water – and the ship would be moving past them. This means that the two events – damage to one compartment and damage to another – are not independent. And this, of course, is exactly what happened. The iceberg didn’t simply puncture one compartment and then bounce off. Rather, it cut into the side of the ship at several points, flooding six compartments.
What we find is that the appropriate way of thinking about what happened to the Titanic is different from the appropriate way of thinking about the lottery. We have to change our model slightly, relaxing the assumption that the events in question (different compartments flooding) are independent. The result is that what the ship’s owners and passengers believed was a highly improbable event in fact becomes quite likely.
I chose the Titanic example because it’s very clear and straightforward: it’s easy to see why the independence assumption is unjustified. In many cases, however, it’s not obvious which assumptions are incorrect – and even very slightly incorrect assumptions can have huge consequences, especially when they interact with other strands of the improbability principle, such as the law of truly large numbers. We live in a complex world, and the different components of a system are often locked in a web of interconnections that are difficult to tease apart. When trying to make sense of them, it is common to assume independence as a first approximation. But this can lead to major miscalculations. The Yale sociologist Charles Perrow has developed an entire theory of what he calls ‘normal accidents’, based on the observation that complex systems should be expected to have complex, undetected, interactions. A frightening thought.
Subscribe to Aeon’s Newsletter
But I should note that the probability lever doesn’t just have adverse consequences. Consider Joan Ginther, a woman in her sixties from Texas, who has won some $20 million from lotteries in four separate wins: $5.4 million in 1993 (though this ticket was bought by her father rather than Ginther herself); $2 million in 2006; $3 million in 2008; and most recently, $10 million in 2010. The first win was from a standard lottery, where you had to pick six numbers, but the other three were from scratchcards.
Now, any strand of the improbability principle can increase your chances of winning a lottery – and therefore your chances of winning more than once. Buying multiple tickets, for example, can bring the law of truly large numbers into play. Ginther is reported to have bought some 3,000 scratchcards per year, spending perhaps $1 million in total on them. A lot of tickets – a lot of chances of winning. But that’s still not enough to make her multiple wins very likely. We need to bring the probability lever into play.
The most familiar kind of lottery is known as an ‘r/s’ lottery, so called because each ticket consists of r numbers chosen from a list of possible s numbers. They are simple and well-understood. Scratchcard lotteries, on the other hand, are more complex – and this complexity provides a crack for the lever to enter.
she periodically bought large numbers of tickets in one go: it’s as if she had cracked the routing algorithm the company used to deliver the tickets
Suppose the Texas lottery operators just sent out all 3 million scratchcard tickets in one go. That would mean that all the winning tickets might end up getting bought very quickly, leaving no incentive for players to buy the remaining tickets. This, of course, would leave the lottery operators out of pocket. And so, instead of spreading the prize money at random over the tickets as they are printed and released, the operators try to make sure it is fairly uniformly distributed.
In fact, the 3 million tickets are released in six consecutive tranches of half a million each, with each tranche containing one-sixth of the prize money. The next tranche is released only when most of the tickets for the preceding one have been bought, which encourages people to keep playing. Analysis of data from the Texas Lottery even suggests that the algorithm keeps at least some of the big prizes for the later tranches, to keep the game interesting. If this is true, it means that the probability of winning one of the big prizes is not uniform – it isn’t the same whichever ticket you buy. And so we find an opening that the probability lever can exploit.
Knowing when large jackpot tickets are likely to be sold is half of the battle. But to be practically useful, you have also to have an idea of where – so that you can buy tickets there. Ginther bought three of her winning tickets in a small town called Bishop in Texas, where she was born, not far from the Mexican border. Although she moved to Las Vegas, she periodically returned to Bishop and bought large numbers of tickets in one go: it’s as if she had cracked the routing algorithm that the shipping company used to deliver the tickets. (For the record, it’s probably worth mentioning that Ginther has a PhD in mathematics from Stanford University and spent some years as a college lecturer in California.)
The story of Joan Ginther shows us one way in which the probability lever can gain purchase on the seemingly impregnable bulwarks of chance. But there are plenty of others. In fact, even some standard r/s lotteries have concealed structures that can serve as a pivot point.
Lotteries, of course, seek to make money for the people or organisations that run them. Their basic mechanism for doing this is to return only a percentage of the total amount paid for the tickets. This means that the expected return for a regular player is less than $1 for every dollar you bet. Players should expect, on average, to lose money. But lottery draws are repeated, week after week, and if the jackpot is not won in one week, it is typically ‘rolled over’ to the next. By buying lottery tickets only when the rollover jackpot has built up substantially, you can boost your expected winnings to more than your stake: then you can expect, on average, to make money.
That’s all very well, but the amount you expect to win in the long term if you keep playing and the chance that you will win it in the short term are two very different things. It is unrealistic to take a long-term perspective lasting thousands of years. What else can you do?
buying tickets only when things were in their favour, several groups made significant sums of money
You might draw inspiration from several groups in Massachusetts. The Massachusetts Cash WinFall was a 6/46 lottery, meaning that one had to choose six numbers from one to 46, with tickets being drawn twice a week. The jackpot began at $500,000 but there were other prizes – of $4000, $150, and $5 – for matching five, four, or three numbers respectively. Whereas many lotteries roll an unclaimed jackpot forward, adding it to the jackpot of the next draw, this lottery rolled it down if it exceeded $2 million without being won: so the lesser prizes, awarded for matching fewer than all six numbers, went up in value.
The Massachusetts groups spotted that if the rolldown exceeded a certain amount, then the total they would expect to win on the cumulated rolldown prizes would exceed what they would have to spend on tickets. Spotting this, and buying tickets only when things were in their favour, several groups made significant sums of money. So much so, in fact, that Cash Winfall was terminated at the start of 2012.
That’s the trouble with the probability lever: sometimes it moves mountains, and sometimes it breaks off in your hand. And of course, when it does, the law of selection means it’s difficult to find another one. Then again, the improbability principle just says that the improbable is commonplace: it’s another matter entirely whether or not you can summon it at will.
Syndicate this Essay
MathematicsSocial PsychologyAll topics →
is Emeritus Professor of Mathematics at Imperial College, London, and chief scientific advisor to Winton Capital Management. His latest book is The Improbability Principle (2014).